Willful or non-willful? Where the IRS draws the line.
Every Streamlined filing rests on one statement: that your failure to file or report wasn't willful. The difference decides whether you pay no penalty or a large one. Here's what the words mean in practice.
The short version
- Non-willful: negligence, inadvertence, mistake, or a good-faith misunderstanding of the law. That's how the IRS defines it.
- Willful: you knew about the requirement and chose not to follow it, or deliberately avoided finding out.
- Most expats who never knew about U.S. filing are clearly non-willful.
- If you're unsure, decide before signing anything. The certification is made under penalty of perjury.
1The definitions
The IRS describes non-willful conduct as conduct "due to negligence, inadvertence, or mistake or conduct that is the result of a good faith misunderstanding of the requirements of the law." Willfulness, by contrast, generally means a voluntary, intentional violation of a known legal duty. Courts have also treated "willful blindness" (deliberately avoiding learning the rules) and, for civil FBAR penalties, reckless disregard as willful.
2Examples
| Situation | Usually |
|---|---|
| Moved abroad, filed locally, never heard of U.S. filing for expats | Non-willful |
| Accidental American who didn't know they were a citizen | Non-willful |
| Local accountant said "you don't need to file in the U.S." | Non-willful |
| Filed U.S. returns but didn't know about the FBAR | Non-willful |
| Ticked "no" to the foreign accounts question on Schedule B without reading it | Depends on facts |
| A U.S. preparer asked about foreign accounts and you said there were none | Risky |
| Moved money to avoid bank reporting, or used nominees | Willful |
3Warning signs the IRS looks at
- Being told about the requirement, by a preparer, bank or the IRS, and not acting on it.
- Answering "no" to foreign account questions you understood.
- Steps that look like hiding: closing accounts after FATCA letters, splitting deposits, using other people's names.
- Sophistication: professionals in finance or law may be held to a higher standard.
4If you're unsure
Talk it through before filing anything. We'll look at the facts with you honestly. If it's clearly non-willful, we'll help you write a specific, truthful statement for Form 14653. If it's close to the line, we'll explain the trade-offs and, where needed, involve a tax attorney so your conversations are privileged. If it's willful, voluntary disclosure is the safer path.
If it's non-willful and you live abroad, the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures are usually the route, with no penalty. Every option, for willful and non-willful cases, is compared in IRS tax amnesty options for expats.
The honest answer is always the right one to build on.
Not sure which side you're on? Let's look at it together.
Your consultation is free and confidential.
Get in touch →Keep reading
Reviewed by Lewis Grunfeld, CPA. General information, not tax or legal advice.